Articles

How Are Business Valuations Prepared?
Valuation Nikki McNeel Valuation Nikki McNeel

How Are Business Valuations Prepared?

For family businesses that have never had an external valuation, there is likely to be some confusion as to what the process involves. In this article, we give a brief walk-through of the valuation process, from engagement through to issuance of the final report.

Read More
Aligning Management Compensation and Shareholder Earnings

Aligning Management Compensation and Shareholder Earnings

The boards of family businesses must find the proper balance between compensation for the management team working in the business and earnings for the family shareholders who own the business. It is likely that some family members will wear both hats, which heightens the challenge of distinguishing the return on labor (management) from the return on capital (shareholders).

Read More
What Time Is It for Your Family Business?
Capital Budgeting Nikki McNeel Capital Budgeting Nikki McNeel

What Time Is It for Your Family Business?

It is harvest time in rural America.  Farmers are working long hours gathering the crops that have been planted, fertilized, watered and worried over since springtime.  While the cycle of planting and harvesting is an annual one on the farm, for family businesses, the cycle can span decades or even generations. There are many different ways to classify family businesses, but one simple distinction that we find ourselves coming back to often is that between planters and harvesters. So what time is it for your family business?  Is it planting season or harvesting season? 

Read More
Why Your Family Business Has More Than One Value
Valuation Nikki McNeel Valuation Nikki McNeel

Why Your Family Business Has More Than One Value

It is understandably frustrating for family business directors when the simple question – what is our family business worth? – elicits a complicated answer.  While we would certainly prefer to give a simple answer, the reality a valuation is attempting to describe is not simple.

Read More
And Now You Know… The Rest of the Story

And Now You Know… The Rest of the Story

Revenue growth and profitability are critical measures for the health of any family business, but by themselves, they tell only half of the story.  As a family business director, you need the whole story.  We’re not aware that Paul Harvey was a financial analyst, but if he were, we suspect his favorite performance metric would have been return on invested capital, because it tells you the rest of the story.

Read More
What Should We Do About Estate Taxes?
Taxes Nikki McNeel Taxes Nikki McNeel

What Should We Do About Estate Taxes?

Family business owners cite different motives for investing their time, energy, and savings to build successful businesses. Some have entrepreneurial zeal, while others are creators who see problems in the world that they can solve. Others are natural leaders who are inspired by the job opportunities and other “positive externalities” that successful enterprises generate for employees and the communities in which they operate. But common to nearly all family business owners is the desire to provide financially for their heirs. As a result, one of the most common concerns such owners cite is the ability to transfer ownership of the family business to the next generation in the most tax-efficient way.

Read More
Five Reasons Your Financial Projections Are Wrong
Capital Budgeting Nikki McNeel Capital Budgeting Nikki McNeel

Five Reasons Your Financial Projections Are Wrong

The good news – or maybe it’s the bad news, depending on your perspective – is that overly optimistic projections are not necessarily the result of intentional errors on the part of your family business managers.  Rather, behavioral economists tell us that humans are prone to overconfidence as a result of what they refer to as cognitive biases. We address five cognitive biases contributing to overly optimistic forecasts.

Read More
How Should We Respond to an Acquisition Offer?
M&A Nikki McNeel M&A Nikki McNeel

How Should We Respond to an Acquisition Offer?

Successful businesses don’t have to go looking for potential acquirers—potential acquirers are likely to come looking for them. Most of our family business clients have no intention of selling in the near-term, and yet they often receive a steady stream of unsolicited offers from eager suitors. Many of these offers can be quickly dismissed as uninformed or bottom-fishing, but serious inquiries from legitimate buyers of capacity occasionally appear that require a response.

Read More
Who’s In and Who’s Out?
Dividends & Redemption Nikki McNeel Dividends & Redemption Nikki McNeel

Who’s In and Who’s Out?

As family businesses evolve, the family’s leaders need to determine the appropriate relationship between membership in the family and ownership in the business. As the third, fourth, and subsequent generations of the family reach adulthood, it becomes increasingly likely that the interests of at least some family members will diverge from the interests of the business.

Family businesses can adopt one of two broad strategies to address this situation: (1) Maintain broad-based ownership and make positive shareholder engagement a strategic priority; or, (2) Use share redemptions and liquidity programs to achieve concentrated ownership among a subset of the family. Neither strategy is inherently superior to the other. We discussed the benefits (and challenges) of developing positive shareholder engagement in a prior article. In this article, we focus on the second strategy.

Read More
Determining the Right Hurdle Rate
Capital Budgeting Nikki McNeel Capital Budgeting Nikki McNeel

Determining the Right Hurdle Rate

If family business directors are going to make good capital allocation decisions, they need to know what the right hurdle rate is.  If the hurdle rate is set too low, the family may experience weak future returns.  Setting the hurdle rate too high, however, introduces the risk that the family business will pass on attractive investment opportunities.  In this article, we consider how the hurdle rate relates to the weighted average cost of capital.

Read More
How Do We Find Our Next Leader?

How Do We Find Our Next Leader?

From the perspective of family business, “Next Man or Woman Up” is one approach that the board of directors can take to management succession. Perhaps for some family businesses, management succession is as simple as pulling the next available candidate from the management depth chart. But we suspect that approach falls short for most family businesses.

Read More
What Is Your Family’s Most Valuable Asset?

What Is Your Family’s Most Valuable Asset?

European investment banking icon Rothschild & Co. recently announced that 37-year old Alexandre de Rothschild will be taking the reins at the firm, succeeding his father at the bank’s May shareholders’ meeting. The new chairman is a member of the seventh generation of the family. While the future performance of the bank under the younger Mr. Rothschild will be the ultimate barometer of success, the Rothschild family clearly has fostered a culture of developing the next generation. Few families have the long history of next-gen development that the Rothschild’s do, but it is a task that becomes more important with each successive generation. The long-term health of any organization ultimately depends on the quality of the rising generation of leaders, and families are no different.

Read More
Is There a Ticking Time Bomb Lurking in Our Family Business?
Dividends & Redemption Nikki McNeel Dividends & Redemption Nikki McNeel

Is There a Ticking Time Bomb Lurking in Our Family Business?

When we talk with family business owners, most confess a vague recollection of having signed a buy-sell agreement, but only a few can give a clear and concise overview of their agreement’s key terms. Yet no other governing document has such potentially profound implications for the business and for the family. My colleague of nearly twenty years, Chris Mercer, literally wrote the book(s) when it comes to buy-sell agreements. Chris and I recently sat down to talk about buy-sell agreements in the context of family businesses.

Read More
Does Father Always Know Best?

Does Father Always Know Best?

Management accountability is hard for any company; effective management accountability within a complex web of family relationships can be an order of magnitude more difficult. Since some family members may fill multiple roles, clear and appropriate expectations paired with measurable outcomes are foundational to a management accountability structure that promotes business sustainability and family cohesion.

Read More
Should We Diversify?
Capital Budgeting, Capital Structure Nikki McNeel Capital Budgeting, Capital Structure Nikki McNeel

Should We Diversify?

The appropriate role of diversification in multi-generation family businesses is not always obvious. One of the most surprising attributes of many successful multi-generation family businesses is just how little the current business activities resemble those of 20, 30, or 40 years ago. In some cases, this is the product of natural evolution in the company’s target market or responses to changes in customer demand; in other cases, however, the changes represent deliberate attempts to diversify away from the legacy business.

Read More